Alright, let's get tactical.

Over the last two emails, I've walked you through:

  • Why gift codes work better than discounts for year-end sales

  • Why low redemption rates make this one of the cheapest retention levers available

Now let's talk about how to actually implement this without screwing it up.

Because I've seen founders get excited about this idea and then accidentally turn it into just another discount tactic.

Here's how to do it right.

The 3 non-negotiables

1. The credit must require a repeat purchase to redeem

This is the whole game.

If customers can redeem the credit without buying again, you've just created:

  • A liability

  • A support nightmare

  • A pure cost center

But when it requires a second purchase, three things happen:

  • Redemption rates stay low (friction is your friend here)

  • Cost becomes predictable and capped

  • Only high-intent customers redeem

Example of good framing:
"You have $30 credit in your account. Use it on your next order."

Example of bad framing:
"Here's 20% off anything, today."

See the difference? One creates a return loop. The other is just a coupon.

2. Timing matters more than amount

The size of the credit matters far less than when you introduce it.

It works best when:

  • The customer has had time to experience your product (at least 2-3 weeks post-purchase)

  • They're approaching a natural reorder window

  • Or they're drifting but not gone yet

It fails when:

  • It's immediate (feels like bribery)

  • It's random (feels manipulative)

  • It's compensating for a bad first experience

This is a reminder, not an incentive.

3. Frame it as stored value, not a discount

Language matters here.

❌ "Here's 20% off!"
✅ "You still have a $30 credit."

One implies continuity. The other implies desperation.

The credit should feel like:

  • Something already owned

  • Something earned

  • Something sitting there waiting

Not like a sales push.

The simple 4-step framework (with AI assist)

Here's how to set this up in fifteen minutes:

Step 1: Decide your offer structure

  • Credit amount (typically $10-$30 depending on AOV)

  • No minimum purchase requirement (you don’t want to seem manipulative)

  • Optional expiration window (I wouldn’t go less than 90 days … you want to seem generous)

Step 2: Set up the technical delivery

Most ecommerce platforms (Shopify, WooCommerce, etc.) offer gift codes and tools like Klaviyo allow you to generate 1-time gift codes as part of automated flows.

Assuming you’re in Klaviyo, set up a flow with a trigger on “placed order” or “ordered product” based on whatever requirement you put in place for your promotion (orders over $100, orders containing product XYZ, etc.)

Step 3: Write your messaging sequence

This is where AI saves you hours.

Prompt for ChatGPT:

"I'm an ecommerce brand selling [your product]. I want to offer customers a $30 gift code when they [the condition of your promotion]. Write me three short email messages:

1. Immediate post-purchase email explaining they've earned credit and giving them their gift code
2. Reminder email at day 30
3. Urgency email at day 75 (credit expires in 15 days)

Keep the tone helpful and friendly. Frame the credit as something they already own, not a discount."

Tweak the output to match your brand voice. Done.

Step 4: Track redemption and iterate

Watch three metrics:

  • Redemption rate (expect ~5%)

  • Time to redemption (most happen in first 30 days)

  • AOV on redemption orders (often higher than first purchase)

If redemption is too high (>30%), decrease the amount of the gift code next time.
If it's too low (<2%), consider upping the offer and check your messaging and timing.

One last thing: this doesn't fix a broken experience

I need to be clear about something:

This tactic amplifies what already works. It doesn't save what's broken.

If your customers didn't succeed with your product the first time, a gift card won't bring them back.

But if they did succeed? This quietly compounds your retention without training discount behavior.

It's a second-purchase accelerator, not a first-purchase band-aid.

Your year-end move

If you're reading this and you still have time to implement something before December 31st, here's my suggestion:

Don't run another flash sale.

Offer a credit instead.

You'll hit your revenue target and set up Q1 momentum.

Hit reply and tell me: Are you going to test this? What's holding you back if not?

I read every reply.

See you tomorrow,

Jeremiah

P.S. If you're thinking "this sounds great but I don't have time to set it up before year-end" … I get it. But here's the thing: you can literally implement this in an afternoon. And even if you wait until January, it works just as well for Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, or any other high-volume period. The calendar doesn't matter. The mechanics do.

100% Typo Guarantee … This message was hand-crafted by a human being … me. While I use AI heavily for my research and the work I do, I respect you too much to automate my email content creation.

There was no review queue, no editorial process, no post-facto revisions. I just wrote it and sent it … therefore, I can pretty much guarantee some sort of typo or grammatical error that would make all my past english teachers cringe.

Anonymous Data Disclaimer … Most of my clients prefer that I not share the inner workings of their businesses or the exact details of the marketing strategies we develop. In order to be able to share my own proprietary intellectual property without violating the sensitive nature of my relationship with them, I often anonymize what I share with you. This may include changing the specifics of their industry, what actually happened, or what we developed together. When I make these changes, I work to preserve the success principle I want to convey to you while obscuring sensitive data. This is necessary.

Keep Reading